Start with two numbers: how long your home could sit and how much carrying cost you can absorb if it does. Marathon's listing counts suggest buyers have plenty of choice, which makes timing your sale the harder half. Test selling first with a flexible closing date before you consider contingencies or bridge financing.
Should you sell first when buying in the Middle Keys?
Selling first is the lowest-risk sequence when buying in the Middle Keys, because you know your cash position before you commit to anything. Buying first, writing a home-sale contingency, or using temporary financing can all work, but each one moves the risk somewhere else: onto your wallet, your offer's strength, or your lender's patience. The right choice depends on your equity, your carrying costs, and how long your current home is likely to take to sell.
Key Takeaways
Marathon had 254 homes for sale and 80 homes sold over the trailing 90 days as of November 2026, so a seller there should plan for a sale that takes time rather than assume a quick one.
Homes sold in Marathon over that window had a median sale price of $955,000 and a median of 64 days from listing to going under contract, before any time to close.
Selling first gives you the clearest cash position, but it can leave a gap between closings that you have to plan for.
A home-sale contingency is a negotiated contract term, not a Florida right, so its deadlines and notice language decide whether it helps you or sinks your offer.
Bridge loans, home-equity lines, and similar tools shift risk rather than remove it, and their terms are lender-specific, so get them quoted before you build a plan around them.
How do the four sequences compare when buying in the Middle Keys?
Each sequence trades one risk for another: selling first risks a housing gap, buying first risks carrying two properties, a contingency risks a weaker offer, and bridge financing risks debt you can't easily unwind. We walk our clients through all four before anyone lists or writes an offer, because the sequence matters as much as the price.
What happens if you sell first?
You get a known cash position and one property to manage, but you may have a stretch with no home to live in. That gap is the real cost of this path, and it's manageable if you plan for it early.
Temporary housing and storage: Decide where you'll live and where your belongings go if the closings don't line up.
Post-closing occupancy: Ask whether your sale contract can include a short period after closing where you stay in the home. That has to be written into the contract, so raise it before you accept an offer, not after.
Offer strength: Once you're sold, you can make a clean offer on the next home without a sale hanging over it.
What happens if you buy first?
Buying first keeps you housed without interruption, but you may have to qualify and fund a down payment while still owning your current home. If that home takes longer to sell than you planned, you carry both.
That means two sets of taxes, insurance, any association obligations, and upkeep. Whether you can do it comes down to your lender's underwriting, your liquid assets, and what you expect to net from the home you're selling. Be honest about the worst case, which is a sale that takes months longer than your plan.
Does a home-sale contingency work in Florida?
Yes, but only if the seller agrees to it and the contract spells it out. The research we rely on doesn't point to any Florida statute that gives a buyer a right to make an offer contingent on selling another home. It's a negotiated contract term, and its consequences depend entirely on the language.
Before you rely on one, the contract should answer these questions:
Which home must sell, and by what date?
What counts as a satisfactory sale?
Must you list your home by a certain date?
How is notice given, and by when?
Can the seller keep marketing and showing the property, and is there a kick-out clause if a better offer arrives?
A seller with other options often prefers an offer without a contingency. Where inventory is deep, as it is in parts of the Middle Keys, a contingent offer competes against clean ones. Whether that's workable depends on the specific home you want and how motivated its seller is.
Can temporary financing bridge the gap?
It can, but it adds cost and a repayment deadline. The tools you may hear about include a bridge loan, a home-equity line of credit, a cash-out refinance, securities-backed borrowing, or a conventional loan structured around your expected sale.
Each has different underwriting, valuation, repayment, and property-eligibility rules, and terms change with the market. Verify current rates and requirements with your lender before you build a plan on any of them. We can tell you what the Middle Keys market looks like, but your lender tells you what you can borrow.
What does Middle Keys inventory say about which sequence works?
The numbers point toward a sale that takes real time, which favors planning your move around your sale rather than the other way around. Here's what recent local market data shows for Marathon, using homes sold over the trailing 90 days as of November 2026.
254 homes were for sale in Marathon.
48 new listings came on in the last 30 days.
80 homes sold over roughly the last 90 days.
The median sale price was $955,000.
The median time from listing to going under contract was 64 days, and that's before the contract-to-closing period.
Do a little arithmetic and the picture sharpens. Eighty sales over about 90 days is roughly 27 a month, and 254 active listings against that pace works out to somewhere around nine to ten months of supply. That's our math from these figures, not a published statistic, and it's a rough guide. But it says buyers in Marathon have choices, and sellers are competing for them.
For a seller, that cuts two ways. If you sell first, expect your home to need a sharp price and clean presentation, and don't schedule your next purchase around a best-case timeline. If you buy first, you may have room to negotiate on the home you want, but you're also betting that yours sells.
How do prices compare across the Middle Keys?
Medians vary a lot from one island to the next, which changes how much equity you may be moving and how much room you have if you're trading across areas. These are area-level medians, and an individual home's value depends on condition, street, build year, and timing.
Source: aggregated public listing data, trailing 90 days, as of November 2026.
Area | Median Sale Price
Marathon $955,000
Key Colony Beach $1,075,000
Duck Key $735,000 (townhomes)
Islamorada $1,464,950
If you're selling in one area and buying in another, that gap is the first thing to run. You can start by browsing our featured Marathon property listings to see what your sale proceeds might buy. We'd rather you see real homes before you commit to a sequence.
What should you settle before you list or write an offer?
Settle your net proceeds, your fallback housing, and the property-specific risks of the home you want, in that order. Buying in the Middle Keys has local variables that can stall a closing, and none of them care about your preferred timeline.
What do you need to know about your net proceeds?
You need a realistic net figure for your current home, because every sequence depends on it. Your net depends on the sale price, your payoff, and your closing costs, which include title and settlement services, recording charges, prorations, any association or municipal charges, and Florida documentary stamp tax. Many of these items are negotiable between the parties in the contract. Documentary stamp tax is governed by Florida Statutes chapter 201, and the Florida Department of Revenue explains how it's calculated and what's exempt. Confirm how it applies to your transaction with your closing agent.
We don't put cost numbers on a blog post, because yours depend on your contract and your payoff. A personalized net sheet is the right tool, and it's the first thing we'd run with you.
What should you check on the home you want to buy?
Check the property-specific items early, because they can stretch a timeline you were counting on. In the Keys that means:
Whether insurance is available for the property, and on what terms.
Flood requirements that apply to that address.
Permit history and any open permits.
Seawall and dock condition, where the home is on the water.
Municipal or association rules that affect how you plan to use the home.
Financing, inspections, title work, insurance, appraisal, and permits all affect how long a closing takes here, and the time from contract to closing isn't uniform across the Middle Keys. Build slack into any plan that has two closings in it.
How do you decide?
Work through it in this order:
Get a net-proceeds estimate for your current home.
Ask your lender what you can qualify for while still owning it, and what any temporary financing would cost and require.
Decide how many months of carrying two homes you can absorb, and how many months of temporary housing you'd accept.
Choose the sequence that fails most gently if your sale takes longer than expected.
We base the sequence on the numbers and the property, not a rule of thumb. Your answer depends on your equity, your home's condition, and the home you want, so the useful next step is a conversation with someone who knows these islands.
If you'd like to see how we work with clients, you can read our reviews on Google.
FAQ
Should I sell my Middle Keys home before making an offer on another one?
Selling first is the safest path for most people, because it removes the risk of owning two homes. The tradeoff is a possible gap in housing, which you can plan for with temporary housing or a post-closing occupancy term in your sale contract. If you're confident your home will sell quickly and you can carry both, buying first may work, but the local numbers argue for caution.
Can I buy a home in the Keys before my current home sells?
Yes, if your lender will qualify you and you have the funds for a down payment without your sale proceeds. You'd also carry both homes until the sale closes. Your lender decides what's feasible, so ask before you write an offer.
How does a home-sale contingency work in Florida?
A home-sale contingency is a term negotiated into the purchase contract, not a statutory right. It makes your purchase depend on selling your current home by a deadline, and the contract language controls the deadlines, notice, and whether the seller can keep marketing the property. Have the exact wording reviewed before you sign.
Will a seller accept my offer if it depends on selling my current house?
Some will, but it's a weaker offer than a clean one, and the seller isn't required to accept it. Sellers who have other options tend to prefer offers without a contingency. Your odds improve if your own home is priced to sell and already on the market.
What happens if my Middle Keys home does not sell before I close on the next one?
You own both homes until the first one sells, and you carry the costs of each. That includes taxes, insurance, upkeep, and any association obligations, plus any loan payments. This is why we ask clients to define their worst-case timeline before they commit to buying first.
The bottom line on buying in the Middle Keys while selling
With inventory as deep as it is in Marathon, plan around the sale of your current home, not just the purchase of the next one. We'll run your net proceeds, test the sequences against your lender's numbers, and show you what your timeline looks like on each path. When you're ready, schedule a consultation and we'll build the plan with you.
About The Brenner Scheel and Casey Team
Kristen Brenner, Tierce Scheel, and Margie Casey bring decades of real estate experience to the Florida Keys luxury market. As Certified Luxury Home Marketing Specialists and the #1 selling team on Duck Key, they have closed over $700 million in sales, with a focus on waterfront estates, luxury residences, and high-performing vacation properties from Key Largo to Key West. Duck Key Realty, founded by the Brenner family in 1977, has operated continuously for nearly five decades from its home office on the Overseas Highway in the Middle Keys.
Duck Key Realty | Florida Keys Real Estate Group · 305-783-3395
Equal Housing Opportunity. Kristen Brenner, Broker / Owner. This article is general information, not legal, tax, or financial advice. Confirm your own numbers with your closing agent, tax advisor, or lender.